Toffee and Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies

If I’m being honest, when it comes to chocolate chip cookies, I’m a purist. In other words, oatmeal need not apply. Nothing against oats, for sure, but they just don’t belong in my version of the perfect chocolate chip cookie — a thick and chewy cookie, preferably large in size, filled with chips, but not too many, a little salty, uber-butterscotch-y, and consumed minutes after leaving the oven.
Here’s the thing though, I’m in cookie-making mode over-drive right now due to a broken leg, and the instant oats (yes, my oatmeal cookies call for instant — sorry, haters) and toffee bits in my cupboard just won’t stop staring at me every time I roll by in my office chair (i.e. makeshift wheelchair). Toffee and Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies | Jessie Sheehan Bakes
And so it was just a matter of time before a toffee and chocolate oatmeal cookie was going to make its way onto this here blog. My jumping off point — like so many classic recipes that I revamp here — was a recipe of my mother-in-law’s  (which looks a lot like this recipe for soft oatmeal cookies), coupled with my own oatmeal chocolate chip cookies for Baked Occasions.Toffee and Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies | Jessie Sheehan Bakes

Melting of the fat (a combo of butter and shortening — the first for flavor, the second to preclude spreading), a yolk, plus an egg, and a bit of Lyle’s Golden Syrup were all in order to guarantee chewiness. The toffee bits plus extra vanilla and more brown than white sugar guaranteed a deeply butterscotch flavor, and the addition of whole wheat pastry flour, rather than all-purpose, seemed an appropriate addition to a cookie filled with oats — although truth be told, you’d never know it was in there. The resulting toffee and chocolate oatmeal cookies filled with — dare I say — the perfect amount of chocolate chips, has garnered extreme praise from the oatmeal cookie lovers in my general vicinity (my book club and immediate family) and i’m inclined to trust them. Here’s to hoping you will, too.[yumprint-recipe id=’90’]
 
s

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *